Sunday, December 18, 2011
Findings Report
Good news! Overall, very positive results came out of the CAT, a summary of which is posted below. The full report is located in the church office and is available for review. Have at it!
Findings Report*
The Church Assessment Tool (CAT) was recently administered in our church. 273 households were sent an authentication letter inviting them to participate and 424 persons were identified in those families as being eligible to take the survey. Of these, 221 persons responded. A response from every member is not required to provide valid results. Holy Cow! Consulting recommends a response goal of 80% of the average weekly service attendance. Our average weekly attendance for the first eleven months of 2011 was 217 people. (0.8)(217) = 174. At 221 responses, we far exceeded the suggested 174 responses.
A summary of the report is provided below. For a complete readout, please review the Vital Signs report located in the church office.
Overall, approximately 72% of our members are clearly satisfied with things in the church. In combination with other questions, this suggests that the morale in our church is very high. Morale is important in a church because it is one of the best predictors of overall health and numeric growth. The indication that our morale is very high suggests that members are highly energized about the ministry of the church.
Members tend to feel positive about their church overall when they also feel that
• persons who serve as leaders in our church are representative of the membership.
• the worship services are exceptional in both quality and spiritual content.
• being part of the church community has given new meaning to their lives.
• the church provides high quality education that is appropriate to every age and stage of life.
• the church prepares our members for ministry by helping them discern their gifts.
The conflict management score for our church is high. Approximately 2% of members are clearly disturbed by the level of conflict. The church has become relatively skilled at dealing with potentially divisive issues that arise from time to time.
Our responses indicate that theologically the church tends to be progressive in its perspective. On the flexible style index, our church appears to be adaptable. This suggests that in the life of our church we may be comfortable making frequent adjustments to the way we do things.
As members look to the future, their top four goals are:
• Make necessary changes to attract families with children and youth to our church.
• Develop and implement a comprehensive strategy to reach new people.
• Develop ministries that work toward healing those broken by life circumstances.
• Expand outreach ministries that provide direct services to those living on the margins of society.
The urgency that members indicate in addressing the above goals is low. This suggests that while members have a clear sense of priorities for the future, there is not a high level of concern that the church must act quickly.
In comparison to other churches, two goals that are unusually strong for our church are:
• Work as an advocate for social and institutional change.
• Make necessary changes to attract families with children and youth to our church.
These may warrant attention from the leadership even if they are mid-level priorities.
All the information in this report should be explored and validated in further conversation. Survey data is not the end of a conversation but the beginning.
* Report submitted by Holy Cow! Consulting and presented at the retreat by Russell Crabtree of HCC; edited by Bonnie Loeser
Questions or comments? Ask or talk to any member of the Vision, Search or Transition Teams. Check out the blog tab above for members of these committees.
- Bonnie
Wednesday, December 14, 2011
Meet the Search Committee
The Search Committee has eleven members representing many facets of the congregation. Here is some information that they wanted to share:
Jeanne Brockmyer is the Chair of the committee. She is a longterm SUCC member, currently involved in the choirs, Health Ministries, and the Personnel Committee. She is passionate about the welfare of children and is involved in research on violent video games. She is retired from UT but still works with several graduate students in clinical psychology.
Anne Reed will be handling the committee’s minutes and blog postings. She describes herself as a “recent” member. Anne keeps busy teaching Sunday School, singing in the Treble choir, and serving on the Board of Christian Education, among other church activities. She was “Mary” for VBS and is directing the Christmas pageant. Anne also keeps busy with her family including her three girls ages two, four, and nine.
Al Compaan is a longterm member (23 years). Among other activities, he is involved in the choir, Stewardship, the Green Team, and the Science and Theology series. He served on the very successful Associate Pastor search committee. Al is passionate about renewable energy and lives in a solar home. He drives an electric truck that he and his family converted in 1999. Al has been married 42 years and has four grown children and four grandchildren. He is retired from UT and helped start Xunlight 26 Solar.
Dave Walker has been a member at SUCC since 1965. His past activities include service as a trustee, deacon, Stewardship Board Chairman, Fellowship Committee, Sunday School teacher, and the Action Auction. Currently he is involved in children’s worship, serves as a confirmand mentor and is a member of the Church Growth Committee. Among his passions are
Rini Ng is a relatively recent addition to the SUCC family. Her activities include the Church Growth Committee, music ministry, Hospitality Committee, and Holy Chow. Her current passions include running in half-marathons and marathons, playing the cello, crocheting, spending time with her husband, daughter and two sons, teaching 6th grade, and raising awareness about extreme poverty through Beads for Life.
Amber Ulrich is a longterm SUCC member. She is a senior at
James (Jim) Overmyer is a relatively recent addition to SUCC. He is a member of the Board of Christian Outreach and the Open and Affirming Committee. Jim also helps the Personal Needs Ministry by doing Food Bank shopping. Jim is a retired public school elementary teacher. He enjoys reading, nature study, yard work, art museums and classical music.
Barbara Eikost is also a relatively recent SUCC member. She serves on the Nominating Committee, and participates in adult Sunday School. She was also a member of the amazingly successful Associate Pastor Search Committee. Barbara grew up in south
Bob Forcht is a longterm SUCC member. He serves on the Stewardship Committee, is an usher team member, and a board member of
Warren Henry has been a member at SUCC since 1972. He has served on many Boards and Committees including Trustees, Diaconate, Endowment, and Pastoral Relations. He currently serves on the Nominating and Endowment Committees, and is a member of the Open and Affirming study group.
Scott Russell is a relatively new member to the church, joining in the spring of 2007 with his then fiancé, now wife, Kate, who is part of the Growth & Membership Committee. He has served on the Fellowship Committee, been involved with Habitat for Humanity, and is excited to be part of the Search Committee. Most of his free time is spent with his 16 month old daughter, Lorelai, his wife, their two dogs, and soon their second child that is expected any day now!
- Jeanne
Wednesday, December 7, 2011
We Are Here: Something to check out on Sunday
We are here: the transition process fully mapped out |
It shows where we are in the process divided up by each team: transition, vision, and search teams.
This graphic is on the left wall when you walk in the parking lot doors.
The graphic is based on Russel Crabtree's method for the transition process. Each step in the process is explained. There are arrows showing where we are in each step. If you have any questions from this graphic, feel free to leave a comment here or contact any of the staff or any of the team members listed in the "About the Blog" page.
Thursday, December 1, 2011
We did it ... and more!
Tuesday, November 29, 2011
Latest CAT update
Sunday, November 27, 2011
Holy Cow! We're moving up!
Thursday, November 24, 2011
We're on our way
CAT count today: 120! Thanks to all who have helped us climb towards our goal of 200 completed surveys -- we've reached the 60% mark.
Sunday, November 20, 2011
The CAT's stats and more
Tuesday, November 15, 2011
The CAT's out of the bag
and found its way to your computer! We hope you received a letter by now describing the CAT survey and explaining how to access it from a computer or, alternatively, to call the church office or pick up one in the gathering area at church. The survey is anonymous and paper copies may be placed in the covered drop box (with an air slot, as Luke points out, for the CAT to breathe) on the table in the gathering area.
Please take the time to fill out the assessment. It took me 25 minutes to complete ... and that included a quick refrigerator check for a snack break.
Your participation is very important and truly appreciated.
Questions, concerns or comments? Please leave a comment below, call or email anyone on the Transition Team -- members' names can be found under the 'About the Blog' tab.
Bonnie
Saturday, November 12, 2011
Why an Assessment
Why are we conducting a church assessment? Why are we asking church members to carve out thirty minutes of their day to participate in a survey? What will we do with the results?
I think we've looked at those questions from the perspective of what we want the church to "look like" in the future, or what guidelines will help us determine the future direction of the church. Those concepts are exactly what the data from the evidence-based assessment are designed to provide us. And we look forward to the findings compiled from the (hundreds of ... right?) returned responses.
How about considering the assessment from a spiritual viewpoint? Russell Crabtree of Holy Cow! Consulting has written an insightful and thoughtful essay titled "Assessment as a Spiritual Journey: A Reflection" and has kindly given us permission to print copies to distribute for our own study and observations. Russell contemplates the merging of fact-driven results with a "robust spiritual practice including prayer, reflection, confession, study and worship."
Copies of "Assessment as a Spiritual Journey: A Reflection" are available in the gathering area of the church. Or you may request one to be sent via email to you -- leave a comment below (no need to disclose contact information; I'll find you if you're in the church directory) or call or email me (Bonnie Loeser -- I'm in the directory).
And please participate in the CAT this week! A letter describing the survey and explaining how to access it from your computer will be in your mailbox early in the week.
--Bonnie
Wednesday, November 9, 2011
Vision Team Update
for one another, and using their skills and talents to serve the church community and the community at large. We do all that we can to maintain and enhance that community by recognizing and valuing diversity, welcoming others who wish to join us on this spiritual and service journey, and by loving and caring for one another, our community and the planet.
We welcome input. Feel free to share your thoughts and ideas with any member of
the Vision Team. Those members are: Lynn Adkins, Pete Hildebrandt, Eric Klinger, Kerry McMurray, Jenni Miller, John Miller, Nancy Settles, Les Schultz, and Al Palmer.
Friday, November 4, 2011
Here comes the CAT
Questions? Please ask!
Sunday, October 30, 2011
Kudos to Our Amazing Staff
Thank you, staff members, for a remarkable 94%participation rate in the Pulse® survey, aka the SAT and SCAT (Staff Assessment Tool and Staff Climate Assessment Tool)!
Your responses -- totally anonymous -- will be evaluated and compiled in a final report to be presented at our December 16-17 Recommendations Retreat.
Your commitment to our church’s future is truly outstanding, and the time and effort you devoted to taking the survey are much appreciated.
Monday, October 24, 2011
The Making of a Vision Statement
Artist rendering of our Transition Team hard at work. |
One of the first steps in succession planning is for the Transition Team to compose a vision statement that reflects our intentions for the process as we move through the months ahead in our search for a new pastor. “A vision for the succession process begins with the imagination.”²
As an exercise to help us get our imagination juices flowing and to discern our goals for the transition, we divided into five work groups of five to six people each at the Foundations Retreat, and each group created its own vision statement.
Interestingly, but perhaps not surprisingly, common elements and themes ran through all five versions. Concepts including communication with the congregation, transparency, engaging members to participate in the process, growth of our church community, a shared future with our new pastor, encouragement to develop new opportunities and ministries and a feeling of ownership of the process by members. The Transition Team then took these five statements and, incorporating the several common elements, constructed its own statement.
Artist rendering of our church feeling positive, informed, involved, and secure (even though they are standing in a bulls-eye). |
Our vision for the succession process is a positive experience in which our congregation feels informed, involved and secure; a process which provides healing from our loss, a clear focus on our mission and call, and that, building on the foundation of Christian community, leads us to our shared future with a new and
differently-gifted pastor.
Keeping these core values in mind -- and putting them into practice -- we will work together to navigate the transition process as we continue the journey.
² BridgeDesign® Field Manual, p. 14.
Sunday, October 16, 2011
We've Been Busy
The retreat took place in Wright Hall. Here's some of the mess we made! |
The upcoming posts will share some of the insights that Russell shared with us.
Tuesday, October 4, 2011
OUR TIME OF TRANSITION
Since Cabinet approved contracting with Russell Crabtree to be our transition consultant, there has been a lot of work happening to begin the succession planning process that he brings and to prepare for the search of our new senior pastor. In the last few weeks, several things have happened:
1. Succession Planning Teams
On Sunday, September 18 at the 10:40 worship service, two teams were commissioned to help us prepare for the search of our next senior pastor.
The Transition Team is a group that will function until our next pastor is called. They are responsible for ensuring that:
• our congregation’s key ministries continue
• the Church Assessment Tool, a part of the process brought by Russell Crabtree, is completed by a vast majority of the congregation
• effective and regular communication about the transition process is offered the congregation
• adopted recommendations of the succession plan are implemented
Members of the Transition Team are Ellen Bowers (co-chair), Marge Cater, Jeff Crandell, Sandy Hauter, Leann Henry, Bonnie Loeser (co-chair), Larry Williams
The Vision Team will build off the existing call, vision, and mission statements to determine
• broad strategies to fulfill existing goals of the congregation
• new strategies and goals for the congregation’s future
These goals and strategies will provide the search committee a framework for the skills and interests that our new pastor will need to have to lead the congregation into our future. The group will begin to meet in October and their work will be concluded by January.
Members of the Vision Team are Lynn Adkins, Peter Hildebrandt, Eric Klinger, Kerry McMurray, Jenni Miller, John Miller, Al Palmer (chair), Les Schultz, Nancy Settles
2. Leadership Clarity Assessment
Congregational leadership has been offered the chance to take the Leadership Clarity Assessment to provide Russell and the leadership a sense of how the congregation views our current ministries and transition. This information will be utilized at the Foundations Retreat.
3. Foundations Retreat
A Foundations Retreat will be held for Cabinet, Transition Team, and Program Staff on October 14-15. The retreat will be led by Russell Crabtree and provide these congregational leaders the opportunity to create a clear plan for the coming months.
4. Church Assessment Tool
Following this retreat, the congregation will receive more information about Congregational Assessment. Every member of the church will be asked to take this survey. More information to come!
5. Pastor Search Committee
A sub-committee of Cabinet has been working to identify members to serve on the Pastor Search Committee. A nominations form can be found in this Intercom. Please return all nominations to the church or email Sue Crescitelli by October 10 for your nomination to be considered. The proposed slate of members for the committee will be presented to the congregation in late October.
Tuesday, September 20, 2011
Transition Expectations by Pastor Luke
I am proud to say that I served under and learned from Rev Bill and the staff he has put together.
In the many meetings since his death, I have learned many things from the ministry team and their knowledge, experience, and history with this church. Susan Rowland Miller and Al Palmer have really helped me understand the need and process of transitions in new ways.They also pointed out that there are at least two experiences and expectations of transitions held in this congregation.
On one hand we have the "old guard" here at Sylvania. They were here when The Rev. Sanford Souers was here and experienced the last transition to Pastor Bill. Al notes that it took a matter of months to find both Pastor Souers and Pastor Bill. So the old guard knows what they want, who they are, and who they want (as in what type) as pastor.
On the other hand we have people who came from Pilgrim church (whom I’ll call “Pilgrim People” here, for the sake of brevity). They have had a bad experience in their last transition and do not have a whole lot of confidence in consultants.
Thus we have two competing expectations in our congregation.
I think the route that is being taken now is a good middle ground for these two views on transition. It makes sure that the work that needs to get done get's done. That way we are not jumping into anything, but that we're clear on who we are and what we want. I think this will appease the Pilgrim People yet the process is fast; much faster than the traditional interim process which will make the Sylvania "old guard" feel comfortable.
I have full confidence in this process mainly because I have full confidence in our people here. Both Pilgrim People and Sylvania OG's as well as those who don't fit in either category are smart people open to new ideas and ways of doing things. That will serve us in the coming weeks and months ahead. I am really excited to see what this brings!
A quick note: It is not my intention to say we have two separate congregations and there is some division between those who came from Pilgrim and those who have been life-long Sylvania members. I have not experienced any divide nor do I see any difference.
We are one congregation and that has been my experience from the start.
What I was trying to point out was the past histories we all bring to the table. To get anywhere, we must acknowledge what we're expecting in the present moment and that stems from where we have been in the past.
There is no them and us, there is only us with our diverse histories within this shared experience of this transition.
Sunday, September 4, 2011
Letter to the Congregation August 30, 2011
We are writing to update the congregation since our last letter. In that letter, we relayed Cabinet’s decision to invite Russell Crabtree of Holy Cow! Consulting to come to the church for a day-long audit process. This invitation was offered in order to learn more from him about his succession planning process and the skills, tools, and experience he brings as a consultant.
Last Monday, August 22, Russell spent the day at our church. Throughout the day he met with members of the ministry team, staff, congregational leaders, and Cabinet. These discussions culminated in Russell presenting a proposal to Cabinet regarding both a process tailored to our congregation to follow through this period of transition as well as the ways in which he felt his services may be of use to the congregation.
After his presentation, Russell left and the Cabinet began the discussion of whether to accept this proposal. In order to provide time to check references and prayerfully consider the proposal, Cabinet met again after worship on August 28. After discussion on the 28th, Cabinet voted to accept this proposal.
The details of this proposal are below. The proposal was approved for a variety of reasons. The first, as we noted in the last letter, is that it provides the congregation a way to maintain the current pastoral leadership while also taking seriously the needed work to understand who we are and the type of leader we need for our future.
Cabinet was also impressed and excited by Russell Crabtree – in particular the experience, tools, and insight that he brings. With 20 years of experience as a pastor combined with an equal number in church consulting, Russell brings with him experience with many congregations and organizations. In addition, Russell specializes in Pastoral Succession Planning and brings with him unique assessment tools designed specifically for succession planning. His process as well as his tools and experience make him the perfect fit for our congregation in this time.
The proposal for our succession process will follow the following schedule:
September 12 Transition Team and Vision Team appointed by Cabinet
By September 30 Leadership Clarity Assessment taken by Cabinet and other leadership of congregation
Sept-Dec Vision Team works on updating Vision and Mission statements with new strategic goals
October 10 Approval of Search Committee by Cabinet in order to send nominations to congregation for election
October 14-15 Foundations Retreat led by Russell Crabtree; Retreat will be attended by Cabinet, staff, and Transition Team; Content will be training in succession planning, setting of a vision for this interim time, and identification of key asset ministries
Oct 16-Nov. 16 Church Assessment and Staff Assessment Tools offered for the congregation’s and staff’s input; This survey will be made available to all congregational members and regular worshippers
December 16-17 Finding Retreat led by Russell Crabtree. Retreat will be attended by Cabinet, staff, Transition Team and Search Committee. Retreat will focus on feedback from the Church and Staff Assessments.
January 2012 Search Committee will incorporate results of assessment tools into Church Profile. Interviews to begin by late winter/early spring. Search Committee will present recommended candidate to the congregation at appropriate time.
The succession process entails three major areas and teams who will lead or manage each area:
1. Transition Team: This group will manage the work that the congregation has that needs to occur between now and when a new pastor is hired. This group will make sure that either they or other groups in the congregation are ensuring that budget needs and revenue opportunities are being met, that there is a process by which the congregation can continue to grieve the loss of our pastor, that staff is supported and that a staffing plan for the future is in place, and that the key ministries of the congregation are continued. This group will also ensure that any directives learned from the congregational assessment are enacted.
2. Vision Team: Our vision and mission statement was written 10 years ago and updated goals were written 5 years ago. It is time for the congregation to again consider our direction and primary needs. Some of this will come from the congregational assessment. But a Vision Team will utilize these materials and learnings from the congregation to update our high-level strategic goals. This work will ensure that we are seeking a pastor who has skills that meet our current needs.
3. Search Committee: The Pastoral Search Committee will take the Critical Ministry Components learned from the congregational assessment and combine this will the Vision Team’s strategic goals in order to create an appropriate profile and then to interview candidates.
We realize that there are some in the congregation who expected a faster process. Twenty-five years ago when this congregation called Bill Chidester, seven months had lapsed between Sam Souers’ resignation and Bill’s starting. This process will only add a few months to our timeline but will allow us to reflect on what changes and future we would like for our congregation and how our leadership may need to be different in the future to respond to those needs. Bill’s tenure here was long and valued. Candidates will be looking to make sure that our congregation has thoughtfully addressed our grief and our hopes for the future. This process will provide that time and reflection.
Other questions and concerns that have been raised are addressed in the enclosed Q&A sheet. Please continue to raise any questions you might have with either of us, or any member of Cabinet.
We know that, once again, a letter can only convey so much information. To that end, we will again be holding an open congregational forum after the worship service on XX. In addition, we are also planning to begin a blog which will provide regular updates to Cabinet and each of the Team’s work. We will be regularly communicating through The Intercom and will be providing an updated visual timeline in the church gathering area in the near future.
We are grateful for the prayers and service that have supported our congregation through these last weeks. We look forward to our future together as we live out our calling as disciples.
In Christ’s Service,
Sue Crescitelli, Moderator Russ Miller, Vice-Moderator
Questions and Answers
Q How much will we be paying Russell Crabtree?
A The contract for consulting and assessment services is $7500 plus expenses (expected to be $1000). This includes Russell’s time, training, as well as the use of the Leadership Clarity Assessment, the Congregational Assessment Tool, and the Staff Assessment Tool. It also includes training resources for the Vision Team and the Search Committee (at no cost) and a Family Tree assessment which will provide the new pastor an understanding of the groups and relationships in the congregation.
Q Where will the $8500 come from?
A Current expenses of the pastoral staff are less than the amount budget for the Senior Pastor’s package (including salary/housing and benefits). There are funds in this year’s budget available to cover the fee and expenses.
Q Is Russell Crabtree a headhunter? Will he be recommending candidates for our next pastor?
A No. Russell will not be involved in the search process for our next pastor. The outcomes of the assessments will provide information for the Search Committee as they prepare the Church Profile.
Q How will the Transition Team, Vision Team, and Search Committee be formed?
A A group of Cabinet members, staff, and pastors has been formed to make recommendations to Cabinet for the persons to be on each team. The Transition Team and Vision Team will be appointed by Cabinet (hopefully by September 12). The Cabinet will receive recommendations for the Search Committee and then recommend to the congregation those names. The congregation will then have the right and opportunity to elect the Search Committee.
Q Will we be looking for an Interim Pastor?
A No. By following the Succession Planning Process and contracting with Russell Crabtree as our Succession Planning Consultant, we will not be searching for an interim Pastor. The current pastoral team will continue to provide worship leadership, pastoral care, and staffing of boards and committee.
Q What are the goals of this Succession Planning Process?
A 1. For the congregation to understand who we are now and who we want to be in the future (and therefore what type of leader we need)
2. To provide opportunities for the congregation to grieve Bill’s death and absence from our congregational life and to prepare for a new pastor coming to serve us
3. To allow lay leadership to lead the process and decisions during this period of transition, ultimately broadening those in leadership positions within the congregation
4. Address staffing needs for the future
5. Ensure administrative needs of the congregation now and for the future are met
Q Who is currently serving on Cabinet?
A Sue Crescitelli – Moderator Grace Bell – Outreach Ex Officio:
Russ Miller – Vice Moderator Jeanne Brockmyer – Personnel David Anderson
Susan Carlucci – Clerk Dennis Dewitz – Church Growth Luke Lindon
Bonnie Loeser – At Large Dave Finn – Trustees Kathy Tashima
Amy Turner-Morgan – At Large Lori Geisler – Children’s Ministries Cathy Hunter
Jacob Long – Youth At Large Brian Green – Stewardship Sally Mossing
Jan Merki – Diaconate Sharon McCord
Nancy Settles – Fellowship Sheila Banerji